Podcast Episode
Episode Description
Our earliest experiences in school shape how we see ourselves as learners, how we approach challenges, and how we feel about learning.
In this episode, I’m joined by Tia Henteleff, educator and author of As We Begin: Dispositions of Mind, Learning, and the Brain in Early Childhood, to explore the powerful role early childhood education plays in shaping children’s identities and dispositions toward learning. We discuss the importance of creating learning environments that nurture curiosity, creativity, confidence, and a positive relationship with learning.
Tia also invites educators to embrace the role of teacher-researcher, approaching their students with curiosity and using what they notice and learn to continually refine their practice. Finally, we explore why designing meaningful learning experiences requires us to consider not only what we want students to know, understand, and be able to do, but also how we want them to feel.
Episode Resources
- Connect with Tia on LinkedIn
- About her book
- As We Begin: Dispositions of Mind, Learning, and the Brain in Early Childhood
Episode Transcript
This transcript was generated using AI transcription tools to support accessibility and provide a searchable, readable version of the podcast. While we’ve reviewed and lightly edited the content for clarity, there may still be occasional errors or omissions.
Catlin Tucker
Welcome to The Balance. I’m Doctor Catlin Tucker, and today my guest is Tia Henteleff, a keynote speaker, author, professional development designer, teacher trainer, and a classroom teacher of 26 years and counting. For the last 15 years, she has created and facilitated research-informed, engaging workshops for educators and educational leaders, both nationally and internationally. And I stumbled onto her work when I read her book, As We Begin: Dispositions of Mind, Learning, and the Brain in Early Childhood. And then I had the absolute pleasure of working with her at an event in Portland a few months ago, where she was working with the early childhood group, and I was working with the upper elementary to middle school group. We just got to chatting, and I loved her ideas and her energy. So I’m just thrilled to have her on the podcast.
Well, I’m super excited. We found a time that worked. Ever since we spoke at the Spear Center event, I’ve been like, I have to get this woman on the podcast talking about her work. So before we dive in, I’d love for you to just tell listeners a little bit about your journey in education, where you started and how you got to the work you’re doing today.
Tia Henteleff
Okay, so first I want to say I’m so thrilled to be here. Meeting you in Oregon was a highlight. Getting exposed to your work was great for me as well, so I’m glad this can happen. My undergraduate degrees were in cultural anthropology and religious studies, and I think I imagined myself being just in the world of academia forever. I loved learning at the college level. I did not imagine myself being a teacher in the classroom. It wasn’t until I was really considering going on to do a doctorate, that I thought about this idea of service and having a positive impact, and then that that kind of led me to this idea of working with children.
Then I had this very casual assistant teaching job at a Reggio Emilia-inspired summer school that just made a huge impact on me and what I saw myself doing for the rest of my life. I was so fascinated by their creativity, their imagination, and the way they were constructing knowledge and understanding who they were in the world. All the enthusiasm and excitement and curiosity that really got me, really got me thinking about this new direction. And then as I began to read how intellectual the work is from the Reggio Emilia approach, how they actually define teachers as researchers. That’s part of that approach. I was doing a ton of reading on Reggio Emilia and realizing that that very specifically spoke to me.
So then I decided to completely switch gears and instead of going to try to do a Ph.D. in religious studies or anthropology, I was looking at education programs, and I ended up going to Stanford, and it was a master’s in curriculum and teacher education, and my emphasis was in visual arts. The job I ended up getting after graduate school was in the lab school on Stanford campus. So now I’m working with children ages three to five, mostly two to five, actually. And I’m in this environment where questioning is always happening, and research is happening, and postdocs are doing work there. The laboratory school, it’s called Bing Nursery School, is affiliated with both the psych department and the education department. And there’s tons of research happening there all the time.
So that became, you know, just part of my first job experience, like this exposure to research and this continuously trying to understand more about what’s happening, what’s developing, and how to best nurture, you know, beneficial dispositions and attitudes and curricula and pedagogy to positively impact learning. So all of that just kind of got my gears going even more. And so here I am, you know, an early childhood educator for 27 years.
Catlin Tucker
Yeah. Well, and it was so funny because when I was speaking with the event organizers and they were asking for, you know, my recommendations on somebody in early childhood, and I don’t have a lot of them, like, I don’t know, a ton of people who have really focused in these early, early years. And then I saw someone talking about your book As We Begin.
And I was like, well, actually. And they were raving about your work. I was like, there’s this woman, and I know she wrote this book, and I’ve never seen her speak, but I think she’d be amazing. And all I heard from everybody at that event was that you are absolutely phenomenal. But what is it about early, early childhood, like this early beginning stage, that is so interesting for you? Because you could have started there and moved around, but you’ve really clearly enjoyed this particular moment of education.
Tia Henteleff
So true. So I think that I had an intuition early on. I think a lot of us do, that the early years are important and they’re foundational and they’re influential. Like, we all kind of understand that on some level. But the more I did research on it and came to understand that 0 to 5 is a consequential period of time to their learning and thriving for the rest of their lives, and that that is a biological fact. The more I really understood that, the more intrigued I was and the more important I felt the work was. Right? I don’t want to do too many computer analogies, but I like to think of it like the hardware is being laid down, and then you get to update the software forever. Right?
That’s emerging forever, but those foundational templates really have impact. So I care deeply about students, about human development and flourishing, and understanding that I can have an impact that lasts the rest of their lives if I start early really perpetuated that idea. For me, it’s also super fascinating. I’m fascinated by how these kids, they’re like aliens, right? Coming to this other planet, they’re learning the language and they’re learning behavior, and they’re creating those associations about what school is, what teachers are like as a concept, what friends are, how to make friends. They are learning so much simultaneously. And it’s just fascinating to go along for that ride, especially if you take that teacher-researcher lens, and I know we’re probably going to talk about this later.
You can learn so much from these young learners. Then there’s another piece to it. That kind of developed over time, which is society doesn’t value and appreciate early childhood educators and education as much as it should. Education itself, you know, doesn’t get the respect that it deserves. And then the younger you go, actually, society sees it as kind of like a less important, less serious job. And that’s just not aligned with the research on brain development and how important the work is. So I’m also committed to elevating the profession, so elevating the way society sees us, but then also elevating our own professionalism so we can meet a higher standard for ourselves.
Catlin Tucker
Yeah. Well, and you write a lot about dispositions of mind and how that’s really threaded through so much of the book and your work, and how critical these early years are. And the messaging that students receive, you know, how will it impact the rest of how they engage in learning, how they think about their teachers,
how they think about classrooms and learning experiences? And to me, that was really interesting because it’s like, of course you want them to start in this place where they’re nurtured and their curiosity is valued and they’re guided in these really kind of research-informed ways to grow and develop. But can you speak to that link and how important it is for young people to have these early moments that set them up to have, hopefully, a positive outlook on what comes next when we talk about schooling?
Tia Henteleff
Yes. So in the book, early on, I ask the reader to think about their own aim in education. Like, what is the point of education? Because I think all teachers need to reflect on that. And I had to reflect on my own. Mine is to help develop this disposition of mind, where the student continuously seeks knowledge and understanding and connection and knows who they are in the world and pursues their interests and finds purpose, that they find a way to make positive impact on others, on society, but they have a sense of meaning and purpose to their lives.
Like, that’s what I want for students. And I know that that is really deeply connected to their self-knowledge narrative, right? Their autobiographical understanding. And that begins early. So when I talk about dispositions of mind, I’m talking about how one feels about learning and thinking deeply. Does it feel good to understand another’s perspective? Right. To think hard or to challenge yourself, and to continuously do that? And if nothing else, I think our world needs a lot more of that in humans. Right. To think more deeply, to seek connection and understanding and to be able to take on another person’s perspective. And connected to that disposition is understanding who you are and the role you play and how your actions impact others. So because I know that self-narrative starts early and gets co-narrated with the teachers and the other humans that are caring for them, that’s why I make it a point to draw attention to it in the early years.
So another researcher that I really love, Doctor Mary Helen Immordino-Yang, she talks a lot about dispositions of mind as well. She does a lot of studies with adolescents, and she does longitudinal studies. So she follows students through college and beyond. And she was lovely. I read all of her work. I follow her. She’s an affective neuroscientist, but I’m writing about early childhood. So she agreed to meet with me, and we spoke for a couple hours on how this idea of dispositions of mind could extend and include early childhood. And she was like, absolutely. It makes sense that this is something we should all be thinking about.
We have to think about it. In high school, teenagers have to see meaning in what they’re learning in school, that it’s not just an imperative for how they do. Right. Like, because you can succeed in school and not really care about what you’re doing. It reminds me of Denise Pope, sort of like doing school. You can, yeah. And we talked about going through the motions.
I mean, that’s kind of what I did in high school. I learned the game. I knew how to get good grades without ever feeling I was really learning. It wasn’t until I got to college that I actually created this disposition of mind for myself. I love learning. And the more you do, the more you understand how things are connected. And the more you see how you can have a positive impact on things, you know, it just propels you more and more. So, yeah. You know, I think it’s imperative that we all, regardless of what age we’re teaching, disposition of mind has to be something that, we think about. And it’s really connected to what we already talked about, with the importance of the beginning and this idea that templates are being laid down, that hardware is being laid down.
And we want these students to have, like a background operating system that’s internalizing this idea that I am a person who can do hard things. I am a person who matters, who has interests that matter, that adults think matter. I have ideas that matter. I can create things. I can have positive impact. Right? Just starting that early and then doing our best to keep it going through school and life. I think that’s the goal.
Catlin Tucker
Well, and it feels like it’s so much easier. And you go ahead and correct me since you’re the researcher on this age range. But when they’re young, they are so open and they are so curious and they want to touch and interact and do all the things that get a lot harder when they’re older. And so it feels like if we lay this groundwork, we intentionally build this strong foundation, this template where they know they have agency, they have ideas worth sharing, they know how to connect with people who see things differently from them. And that’s not scary or bad. Oh my gosh, we need more of that right now for sure.
But then it’s so much easier to build on that. Whereas if they don’t get that early on, trying to overwrite a system or restructure a template, like the older they get, the harder it feels like that can be. Unless it’s somebody who, like yourself, is, you know, a self-starter in college and just decides, you know, like, I’m going to leap in and I’m going to do things a little bit differently. So I love that focus on the early years. And it makes a lot of sense. Somebody who researches adolescents would be like, yes, let’s get this party started sooner.
Tia Henteleff
Yes. I think that that is true. Yeah.
Catlin Tucker
Yeah. And something that you wrote about, too, that really struck me because I do a lot of work in the K-12 space. And you just don’t hear this emphasized very much is we spend a lot of time identifying what we want students to know and understand and be able to do. And your book kind of invites us to consider, what do we want them to feel like?
What is that emotional experience? And sometimes I feel like we’ve almost plucked that out of the educational equation. We’re not talking about it. But when kids spend the vast majority of their days in these spaces with this community or these people, we should absolutely be thinking about how they’re feeling and how that might influence the learning that’s actually happening in these spaces.
Tia Henteleff
Right. Well, there’s a lot of research on the inextricable link between cognition and emotion. Right? You cannot take emotion out of cognition. You know, we have the brains that we have, right? And we’re a social species, and we have a limbic system that’s going to tag things as either safe, let’s approach, or unsafe, let’s run away. We have a reward system in our brain, right? So with things that feel good, we’re naturally drawn to do them some more. It also increases our focus. So why wouldn’t we, knowing that, use that to enhance learning? Not just for the sake of achievement and performance, which is what we spend a lot of time thinking about in schools. Right.
And this might be easier for me to do as an early childhood educator, but I really like to keep looking at the big picture. what do I want for this individual for their life, not just for the 9 or 10 months that I have them in my class, right? And the more I think about that, I mean, there’s so many reasons why we need to take their feelings seriously.
Right? And the other piece is, look, you know, I love that now there’s a lot of attention on relational intelligence, because there’s a lot of talk about AI and what AI is going to do and what AI is not going to be able to do. We think, right? We’re all theorizing here. But I mean, AI isn’t going to turn into humans. We as humans, we need other humans, right? We’re always going to need relationships. We’re always going to flourish in relationship. So understanding your own feelings and how that connects to what you do and the way you react and respond, and how that either propels you to do good or to not do good. Understanding that about yourself and understanding that about others, I think it was always important, but maybe we’re going to see that it’s even more important. We need to be able to relate to others. We need to be able to work with others. We need to be able to support others. And as teachers, we do this work all the time. You know, we have to understand.
I know we can pretend like emotions can be parked at the door, but we know that’s never going to happen, right? They’re with us whether we want them to be or not. So I think we have to kind of own that as a human superpower and enhance our emotional intelligence, enhance our social cognition, so that we can continue to thrive as a species.
Catlin Tucker
Yeah. Well, and what I see from my vantage point when I work with educators working with kids in middle school and high school is that we’re also in this strange moment where I could not agree more. I think everything that makes us uniquely human is going to be increasingly important as the AI explosion continues. But we are also seeing these trends in the upper grades where kids don’t want to talk to each other. They’re uncomfortable working together. They just would prefer to do stuff on their own. And it’s almost like, I don’t know if it’s a combination of post-COVID or the fact that they stare at these little screens all the time and they don’t have that confidence in those interactions.
But I feel like we need an emphasis on this. Are we constantly helping students to navigate these situations together, build these skills so they can be more confident? I think it’s going to be an increasing area that we have to be nurturing and thinking about. And I think it’s also going to, you know, quite frankly, cause some bigger ripples and hopefully big conversations among educational leaders in this kind of moment where teachers are being tasked to cover all of this information and content. And actually, we’re losing a lot of that humanness of the learning, the social interaction, the interactive pieces. There are all of these tensions always in education, but I feel this one starting to bubble up to the surface.
Tia Henteleff
Right. We need to raise humans that could fluidly navigate complicated social dynamics. We need that. We need that at school. We need that after school. We need that in the workforce. We need that in the boardroom, wherever you are, we need those skills. Those are complicated skills. They’re not going to just happen because, you know, they turned 18. So these skills have to be explicitly taught. You know, a lot of people talk about how social skills are explicitly taught in kindergarten. And I actually think they might be taught less and less in some schools. But they need to be explicitly taught and practiced, right? It’s not just like, let’s do an SEL lesson.
“Okay, now they’ve got it. Move on.” We need to practice the same way we need to practice any skill to build those neural networks, right? So they need to be practiced when they’re little, and then things change, right? In middle school, they become aware of their self-identity in different ways, and the importance of reputation now has a whole new weight to it. I think they need to be retaught explicitly in middle school and in high school. And again, given just a ton of practice. You know, and that starts with being given the vocabulary so you can talk about feelings and emotions, and having practice with metacognition so you can think about your own thinking and how feelings are impacting you.
Right. That needs to be taught and practiced throughout. And how to be your best self and how to respond to a situation as opposed to react, and to take all this into account. The idea is that eventually we get so good at this stuff that we’re not always putting out fires.
Catlin Tucker
Right.
Tia Henteleff
Imagine just like walking into a room, like a teacher meeting or a board meeting or whatever meeting where all the adults have, like, you know, really high social cognition. Yeah, right? That would be delightful. People would feel good.
They’ll feel heard. They’ll feel a sense of belonging. You know, it’s productive, right? There’s so many reasons why we need this. And I think you’re right. I think we are combating a lot of post-COVID realities, behaviors, and habits that we’re still trying to understand. And I think that I’ve seen with my own kids, like, there was a lack of confidence, like social confidence after being home on their computer for a year and a half.
That made sense, right? Especially my youngest. We switched to another school, so they had to start all over. That was rough. And so if they lost some confidence and self-efficacy in their social skills, right at the time when kids are more judgmental of each other, of course they’re going to find comfort in their phone. Right? So if that’s going to happen outside of school, it actually makes it seem like it’s even more incumbent on us to create opportunities for them to develop relational intelligence and social cognition at school. And why not? You know, I’m always talking about the importance of conversation and discussion.
Catlin Tucker
Yeah.
Tia Henteleff
You know, yeah.
Catlin Tucker
But I think the tension, too, is that you’re absolutely right. All of these skills need to be taught. They need to be practiced. They need teacher feedback to make sure kids are kind of like doing things in a way that’s productive and respectful and supportive. And that all requires kind of going slow to go fast, right? You have to invest the time and energy. And I actually think early elementary, early childhood educators are incredibly skilled at this. They have to onboard kiddos to everything. And so they get it. Like, we can’t do X, Y, or Z until they learn how to do this first with confidence and capacity. But then you get into middle elementary, upper elementary, middle school, high school, and we’re no longer teaching things like discussion protocols or reflective practice routines.
Right. Because they do take explicit teaching and it’s not our content. And we’re like, wait, we only teach our content. It’s like, no, we have to teach all of the skills that these students need. And when I talk about student-led learning, which was my focus at the Spear Center, it’s like, I’m not saying kids are leading every aspect of the learning. In fact, in order to lead their learning, they need us more in the early stages to set them up for success. But like, how do we get teachers and school leaders supporting that investment of time, that explicit teaching of things that are not, like, the standards?
Tia Henteleff
I know, I know. Well, that goes back to that emphasis on content and standards and the way I’m trying to push the conversation more to dispositions of thinking. And and I can think of a good example of something that happened in my second-grade class. We just did a unit on Mars rovers, and they got all the background knowledge.
You know, we spent the time learning about Mars, why we care about Mars, the terrain of Mars, the climate of Mars. And then they learned about the history of the Mars rover missions. And they had to memorize that part. I had them do lots of active retrieval every day. They had to recite to me what the mission is, what the point is, because I needed that to be in their working memory, because then the next thing I had them do is to invent the next iteration. And I said, you can think outside the box, guys. You can invent some other technology to put on your rover that hasn’t been invented yet. So really think outside of the box. And they started with 2D designs and they were so invested at this point. And, I mean, every single student was so invested in their designs and it was up to them how many rough drafts they did until they had their final draft that they were proud of.
Right. So they’re not just like rushing through it to get the check, right? They really wanted to be proud of it because once they had their final draft, then they were going to make a 3D model of their final draft using LEGO bricks. And I let them know that now you’re introducing a new medium. And so now you’re problem-solving with a new medium. And so you’re going to have other obstacles, and you are probably going to have to be doing some iterating. Right. Because it’s going to be really hard to make a 3D model that’s really true to your 2D model. So they worked on these. When they finished, they presented them to the class, to their peers,
The rest of the second graders, explaining all the components of their Mars rover, what it was used for. Now, before we did this, I had to explicitly teach them how to give feedback because I was going to ask them to give feedback to their peers. But if I just said, okay, now give feedback, it was probably not going to land well, right? Right. And to your point about explicitly teaching that process, that routine, I did it on other things first. Their first experience of giving feedback, which we actually called feedforward because it just feels better, it’s like, this is to improve future work. Right? So before they gave feedforward about these Mars rovers that mattered so much to them, they were so proud of their designs, so invested.
Catlin Tucker
Yeah.
Tia Henteleff
Yes, so invested. We practiced with silly things that didn’t matter so much. We did little skits. Like I would tell a student to pretend to be a toaster. They had to pretend to be a kitchen appliance. Okay, so this is playful. It’s fun, right? You have to act out an appliance. Your peers are going to guess what kitchen appliance you’re acting out, and then they’re going to give you feedforward. They didn’t care so much about their performance as a toaster or a blender or a vacuum, right? But they had the chance to practice giving and receiving feedforward. And the other way that I supported that process is I gave them sentence stems. You begin a suggestion with “I suggest,” blah blah blah, or “I recommend,” blah blah blah, or “I have an idea.”
So I also explicitly told them not to use the word should, because if you say you should have or you should at all, it’s going to be hard to hear and they’re not going to receive your good idea. Right? So we practiced with that and they helped each other. So by the time they’re giving each other feedforward about the Mars rovers, they were giving each other really authentic, very useful feedforward comments that I wrote down and then gave them at the end. I said, okay, here are the feedforward comments you received.
Which ones are you going to use for your next iteration? So the creative agency is still back on the presenter, the builder. Right. They get to say, like, I don’t think I need more storage for specimens, but I do like the idea of a robotic arm with a claw. Right? So they still have that opportunity to own their design. Right? And they all did it for each other.
Catlin Tucker
I love that the feedback was during the process. They could take it if they thought it was useful and act on it, which is what feedback should do.
Tia Henteleff
Yeah, yeah. If you can’t act on the feedback, then there’s really no point in the feedback. It’s really just going to be criticism. But yeah, right.
Catlin Tucker
Oh my gosh. Listening to you, it’s so funny because when I was in a seventh-grade class and a teacher wanted to use Four Corners, the strategy where students select an option, they go to a corner, they circle up, they have a conversation. It can be used for everything from activating prior knowledge to checking for understanding.
But they’d never done it before. And so we were walking through the process and I said, well, let’s do it with questions that are not academic. They’re going to function more for kids to connect, share their opinions or thinking about things. And it was very similar where we spent the better part of 30 minutes onboarding them to the process, practicing with options that were low stakes so they could kind of like make the mistakes that are going to happen.
We could give gentle feedback, and we could try again. And I think so often those steps, it’s like we assume young learners need them. And as they get older, they don’t. And then what ends up happening is when we don’t explicitly teach those things, teachers are so scared of, like letting kids have a small group discussion or use a strategy that asks students to lead because they’re like, I don’t think they can do that. And I’m like, I don’t want to hear that. They can’t do it if we haven’t explicitly taught it and practiced it and given them feedback. So I love that reminder. And just for the listeners, like all students need it. All students can benefit from this.
Tia Henteleff
Yes.
Catlin Tucker
Absolutely. And go ahead.
Tia Henteleff
I was just going to say I’m so glad I didn’t feel threatened by receiving feedback from my peers in college and graduate school, because I don’t know if I would have gotten through it without it. You know, I didn’t write a single paper in college or graduate school that I didn’t pass around to my friends to get their input on. I mean, I can accept their suggestion or not, but it’s just going to make me think harder, more deeply, and turn in a better paper. Right?
Catlin Tucker
Oh, I could not agree more. I feel like that whenever I write a book and I get an editor, I’m like, do not be shy. Push back, give me feedback, challenge my thinking or my organization. That’s what’s going to make this a better book. Yeah, for sure. So I do want you to talk about this teacher as researcher, or teacher-researchers, because when I hear that phrase, I was like, yes, it reminds me so much of something that I say a lot when I work with teachers, which is like, I want you to be the lead learner in the classroom. I want you to always be learning. And to me, the teacher-researcher lens is such an interesting way to reframe our work in classrooms. So I’d love for you to just unpack that. Share what you mean by that with listeners.
Tia Henteleff
Yes, I’ll share what I mean. And I have to give credit to others too, because, like I said, the Reggio Emilia approach. I worked at a few Reggio Emilia schools. There’s lots of versions of it, but my job title was teacher-researcher. It wasn’t teacher, it was teacher slash researcher. That’s how seriously they take it. Whenever you slow down to really pay attention to the way kids are understanding and conceptualizing the world, you have a researcher lens. I mean, we’re researchers anyway. We’re collecting data. We’re iterating, right? We’re analyzing. We’re coming up with strategies. We’re all doing it, whether we are using that language or not. On some level, we are already researchers. I just think that given the amount of both specific and generalized knowledge that we need to teach all students, with all the variability that comes our way, there’s no one instructional model. If everything was so lockstep and predictable, then maybe you wouldn’t need human teachers anymore. Possibly, right?
I mean, you’re always going to be the human, but the human has the power to relate to another human and try, at least try, to understand all the interconnected variables that are behind a certain behavior or a lack of behavior. Right? So there’s not one neat reason why a kid can or cannot do something. Everything is so context dependent, right? So, you know, if we’re doing our job, we’re going to be constantly questioning and looking, tracing the why behind the why, behind the why. It’s also just way more interesting for me as a teacher to approach it that way. I want to be a lifelong learner. I know that if I orient myself that way each year. So I’ve been doing it for 27 years. Right. And I know that I have a lot of experience and a lot of ideas, and I have a repertoire of strategies, but I’m always looking for more, you know, whenever I stop looking for more, then I don’t think I should be a teacher anymore because the variables are constantly going to change. Right?
We don’t even know what variables are going to walk in tomorrow or next month or next week. So, yeah, I also talk about how there’s reading research from academia, and then there’s actually doing classroom action research. And for me, I do a little bit of both.
But just having the lens of seeing yourself as someone that is continuously growing and learning, not just from books and studies and articles, but from the students themselves. What are they telling you? What is their what could their behavior be telling you? What assumptions might you be making? All of those things are just going to help us do our job more.
Catlin Tucker
I feel like when I listen to you talk, I think of what high-functioning professional learning communities are designed to do together, which is almost like action research in their classes, and then being able to come together and say, okay, this is what we did. This is what we saw, this is what we’re seeing. Here’s kids’ work. What are we thinking about it? How do we respond to it? Let’s do it together as a community of teachers. Because I think the more you go in with this mindset of, I am a teacher-researcher, I’m going to learn about this unique population of kids and what works for them and what doesn’t, and what’s going on behind the scenes,
Then we come from this really positive place of curiosity as opposed to what I worry happens, which is, I guess I’m a teacher who came out of credential school or teaching program with this set of skills, this instructional approach, and it’s not working. And so something must be wrong with these kids in this class that this isn’t working as opposed to seeing this diversity of need, this variability, as a puzzle I want to try to solve with these kids. And that is absolutely the mindset that I would love for teachers to have. And I think the best teachers that I have the privilege of meeting and working with are those curious learners. They really want to understand kids and try to meet them where they’re at.
Tia Henteleff
Yeah, yeah. Like I said, there’s not going to be one neat reason behind a student not being able to do something that you want them to do. There’s going to be interconnected reasons, and we might not ever grasp all of them. You know, the other piece is there’s no one strategy that works for all students all the time.
Catlin Tucker
Sure.
Tia Henteleff
Yes, totally. You know, and we’re talking about really dynamic systems that are being affected by so many things, you know, their home experience, what happened in the hallway, what happened with your boyfriend or your girlfriend or your best friend or your grandma? I mean, all of these things are impacting all of us all the time. So that’s why we need to stay curious. And I can think of some examples. I use research with my own teaching all the time, just because I’m always learning and thinking about how that applies to my own pedagogy and how that can change my project and my approach. So I do that anyway.
But I can think of a practice that I started doing that was straight out of the research. So I was paying attention to Doctor Adele Diamond. Her work is on executive functions. She was talking about this Tools of the Mind program that Doctor Bodrova and Leong were developing. Right. That that research led me to their research, and they had developed this, approach called play plans to help foster executive function skills in early learners. Right. And so, you know, that’s what I’m working with. So I was really intrigued by this. Like they have the research behind it. The rationale makes sense.
So I read all about how they use play plans in their programs, and I can’t do exactly what they do in my classroom. So I thought, well, how can I adapt that? Can I try a version of this and see what happens? So I thought, okay, I’m going to try something. I don’t know anybody else who’s done this, but I’m going to try it. And it was amazing. Like the impact on what I was seeing with kids being able to verbalize a goal and then a plan that was aligned with the goal and then self-monitor their actions against that goal and then reflect on it later, like, there was this whole process that I created about play plans, and I could see. all the development over the year with pre-K. Okay, so with four- and five-year-olds.
Catlin Tucker
Wow.
Tia Henteleff
Then the happy side effects were that social relationships were burgeoning. That was great. Their imagination was burgeoning because we were taking the time to share our play plan ideas before going outside. So as the year progresses, their ideas get more imaginative because they’re getting inspiration from each other.
So I’ve been doing that for 20 years and it’s just always a win. And I’ve been sharing this practice. I tell people about the original research and I tell them like how I adapted it for me, and maybe you can find some adaptation that works for you in your classroom. And I just got a text from a teacher I used to work with saying that she’s incorporated play plans back into her classroom, and she said, they’re so involved and they’re so reflective about their play plans now. So, I mean, that’s just an example of how you can use research, right? But you can’t do it exactly. I didn’t do exactly what they did. And then of course I have more examples. But I mean, that’s what makes the work so fun and fascinating and interesting for me, especially when I try something that works so well. Sometimes it doesn’t really work, but that’s okay. Maybe there’s an iteration. Maybe I can try something else next time.
Catlin Tucker
Or maybe that spaghetti just didn’t stick and it’s okay.
Tia Henteleff
Exactly right. We have to be open to that. Yeah.
Catlin Tucker
Have you written about play plans somewhere? Somebody’s listening to this and they’re like, oh my gosh, I want to learn more about this.
Tia Henteleff
I often get asked to present on play. And when I do that, I usually get into that example. I think it’s in my book. It is in my book a little bit.
Catlin Tucker
Okay. I have to dig in. I’m going to dig in and I will link to your book. But like as somebody who talks about metacognition and like the importance of it and usually more like upper elementary through high school, I love the idea that you can start fostering this on a play level with young learners. It’s so cool. Yeah, yeah.
Tia Henteleff
We could talk for 45 minutes about that.
Catlin Tucker
I know we’re going to have another episode together. We’re going to need to do that. The parallels are fascinating. So before I let you go, I always end the episode asking my guests to share any tip, routine, or strategy they have for trying to maintain a healthy-ish work-life balance. Is there anything that works for you that you want to share?
Tia Henteleff
Okay, I’m going to put the teacher-researcher lens back on. I think it’s that, because if something is not working, then I know to take the time. And I mean, if it’s not working for the kids, but also if it’s not working for me, what is that? If something is not working for me, if I’m not feeling good, then I know the kids are going to pick up on that.
I know that for sure. So it really is constantly changing. I’m going to give you a very current one. So if you ask me this question next month, I might say something different, but currently, I started off the year with these kids being so excited to be in my class. And I guess let me back up. I teach design science, so I teach STEAM for preschool through second grade. I was a homeroom teacher for the majority of my teaching career, but this is my fourth year being the design science teacher in a lower school.
I’m also the lower school research lead for the center. But my students, I really do feel like this year, more than other years, they love to come in here and they love to engage. And that makes me feel good. And so there’s this whole, like, positive reciprocating feedback loop that’s happening right now that I want to maintain. And what I found out is if I just give myself a little bit more of a buffer, I try to get less done in the lesson.
I have them for 40 minutes, so I plan for 30 minutes. I don’t plan for 40 minutes. I plan for 30 minutes. So I’m not stressing about losing five minutes here and five minutes there. I can slow my pace, right? I can be more responsive to what they’re saying they need, and we can end in a relaxed way. I can close the class in a relaxed way with a smile on my face and, you know, hopefully with smiles on their faces too. So that’s it. Because, you know, we’re all striving for balance. I work at a school that’s very, like, we’re go-getters here. We work really hard. We have long days.
I’m not going to be able to change that. You know, I’m not going to be able to work less. So I have to enjoy my work more. And so that’s what’s working for me.
Catlin Tucker
Tia, I want to say you have got to be somewhere in the neighborhood of guest 100. And that is the first time anybody has ever offered that piece of advice. And I have to say, it hits me right in my chest. I think this is something I’m trying to learn as a professional learning designer and facilitator, because I know I have such limited time with a group of humans, and I’m like, I just want to make the most of it. I want them to get all of these things out of it. And then I have days where I walk away and I’m like, I wish I had tried to do less. Because I think, you know, the way we talk about kids learning, it’s like you can only take in so much new, and I don’t want to rush people through stuff.
And I just think it’s so beautiful to be like, I have this amount of time, but I’m actually going to plan for a little bit less time so that I’m less stressed. I can lean in and enjoy it. I just think that’s such good advice.
Tia Henteleff
Okay, good. I needed to hear that. Really. Yeah.
Catlin Tucker
Oh, well, thank you so much for spending this time with me. It was an absolute pleasure to get to talk with you.
Tia Henteleff
Oh, I loved that, Catlin. Thank you.
Catlin Tucker
Well, I’ll definitely have to have Tia back on the podcast, because my mind is spinning in all of the directions that I would love to have taken the conversation. I’d love to pick her brain more about the role of play in early elementary, but also how we think about weaving that into, you know, grades as they get older.
Like, what is the value of play and learning? I love the focus on how students feel. Like, how do we want them to feel in a learning environment as they engage with a task, an activity, with the learning itself? I was really fascinated by the parallels as I was reading about everything from dispositions of mind to thinking about how the brain works and how we, you know, focus on helping students develop their metacognitive skills or executive functioning, how that work can start when they’re young.
But we can thread it through their whole journey through school. There’s just so many interesting, like I said, parallels between early education and the years that follow as students progress through the grades. So just really appreciate her perspective, her energy, the research she’s done, and the reminder that we as teachers should be teacher researchers really striving to learn about our students, who they are, what’s working for them, how to make adjustments to improve the experience, right?
Really approaching our work with students from this place of curiosity and from a desire ourselves to continue learning and growing in this work. I want to thank you guys for joining me for yet another episode of The Balance. And for this conversation, I will include links to Tia’s book in the show notes, as well as ways you can contact her if you’d like.
Hopefully I can talk her into writing a blog post with me about metacognition in the early years that I’ll be able to share with you all at some point in the future. And if you haven’t had an opportunity to rate the podcast, I would love for you to take a second wherever you listen and post a review for me. Just helps other people find it. So I appreciate your time on that as well. And as we head into the Thanksgiving holiday, I hope you all have some time to rest, relax, connect with the people that you love, and have a little time for yourselves. So I will see you back here in a couple weeks.

No responses yet